CityNavigator map layer

[JungleJim]

I have several OSM-based maps, City Navigator EU NTU, Topo Active Europe and the free Abruzzo TrekMap Italy map on an SD card in my GPSMAP 67.

When I activate a single routable OSM-based map in Map Manager (and keep all other maps disabled), the CityNavigator map layer is also enabled, which I wouldn't expect to happen.

When I disable the CityNavigator map layer, all routable OSM-based maps are disabled as well.

And when I re-enable the CityNavigator map layer, the City Navigator map is enabled (as expected) but also all OSM-based maps. The Abruzzo TrekMap Italy map stays disabled.

I had the impression this was working correctly before device software version 7.60, but I'm not sure anymore so I'm wondering if others can verify or remember how this was working?

[GPSrChive]

This has always been an issue with devices that allow maps to be enabled/disabled collectively.

The reason is that all (or most) third party maps secretly identify as CityNavigator maps, so when CN is toggled, they also are toggled.

It is up to the map makers to properly code their maps so this does not occur.

[JungleJim]

Thanks, I indeed had the suspicion that this is being caused by the fact that the 3rd party maps are routable.

Do you happen to know how map makers should code their maps then? Is there any flag or header data that could prevent this from happening?

[Nail]

For me the map layers menus make no sense at all. Additionally, you cannot turn off individual Topo maps provided by Garmin and they are provided as a layer. Unnecessary confusion.

[GPSrChive]

Additionally, you cannot turn off individual Topo maps provided by Garmin and they are provided as a layer.

Have you tried this in the hidden Trip Computer Test Page?

See GPSrChive > GPSMAP 67 > Troubleshooting > Hidden Test Pages for details.

[Nail]

Have you tried this in the hidden Trip Computer Test Page?

See GPSrChive > GPSMAP 67 > Troubleshooting > Hidden Test Pages for details.

I have to check it, but it is not an option for an ordinary user.


Are there any GPSMap67 users on the forum, who have an Outdoor Maps+ subscription?
If so, is there an additional layer related to these maps in the map layers?

[GPSrChive]

All available Outdoor Maps+ layers will be available via the Map page Map Layers menu.

See GPSrChive > GPSMAP 67 > Pages > Map > Map Layers for details.

[Nail]

The hidden test menu has map switches. Of course, Topo Europe is not divided into areas as it was in GPSMAP66sr.

Spoiler

hidden test menu.jpg

The map manager does not have such switches for TOPO maps. It's an error.

Spoiler

Menager maps.jpg

[Nail]

It is up to the map makers to properly code their maps so this does not occur.

The creator of the device should make sure that mapping companies have knowledge of how the device will work. After all, maps existed before 67 was created. I don't know why Garmin assigned OSM maps to CN? Especially since the new TOPO is based on OSM. The inability to create your own layer also undermines the point of this menu.

[GPSrChive]

It is up to the map makers to properly code their maps so this does not occur.

The creator of the device should make sure that mapping companies have knowledge of how the device will work.

Garmin maps use proprietary code developed exclusively by Garmin Software engineers. Garmin have ZERO obligation to share this intellectual property.

Those who use Garmin products are incredibly fortunate they are not prevented from using third party maps on their devices. Many users do not properly appreciate this concession.

It is solely the responsibility of third party map makers to ensure their maps will work properly with the devices they are created for.

After all, maps existed before 67 was created.

And 99% of these third party maps were created improperly.

I don't know why Garmin assigned OSM maps to CN? Especially since the new TOPO is based on OSM.

Your 'facts' are wrong. Garmin did not assign OSM maps to CN.

The fact is most third party maps are coded as CN when they are created.

The inability to create your own layer also undermines the point of this menu.

What do you want to create? Which menu are you referring to?